Virtual Currencies: The Legal Problem and Future Outlook
Dr. Jamal Abdulaziz Omar Al Othman
Assistant Professor of Commercial Law
Imam Malik College for Sharia and Law,
Dubai, UAE
Abstract:
This research aims to study the legal problem of virtual currencies and its impact on shaping the future by employing them to improve the economic and investment status of countries and societies, and by shedding light on these emerging tools, which have raised – and continue to raise – many questions and problems, by being digital units that do not have a tangible physical entity. They are produced by computer programs which are not subject to the control of central banks, and they are traded among their dealers, either for the purpose of speculation through electronic platforms, to be exchanged by their dealers for cash currencies, or to be used as a fulfillment tool accepted by sellers, in exchange for their goods or services offered to the public.
“Bitcoin” is one of the most popular virtual currencies that was issued in 2009, followed by “Litecoin”, “Nimoken” in 2011, “Bercoin” in 2012, “Ripple” in 2013, “Dash” in 2014, and “Ethereum.” in 2015, and “Feathercoin”, “DinarCoin” and “Zcash” in 2016. Virtual currencies raise many problems related to their nature, types, risks generated by them, and what distinguishes them from conventional currencies, such as: cash currencies and electronic money that represent a cash value stored on an electronic means paid in advance, as well as the characteristics of virtual currencies, their legal nature, and the regional and international position on them.
Virtual currencies pose many risks and challenges, either to their parties, or to their ability to be a fulfillment tool, or to the challenges they pose in facing laws and regulations. In sum, these risks and challenges are represented either in the lack of liquidity and system failures, or in the theft of currency from customers’ accounts, or due to the fluctuation in its value as a result of the speculations that take place on them, in addition to the fact that the majority of countries and their central banks, and international bodies, have not recognized it as money until now. It is also believed that virtual currencies may be a means of money laundering, terrorist financing, tax evasion, or fraud operations with the intent to seize money by offering fake currencies, or through illegal trading platforms.
There is almost unanimity among the governments of countries and international bodies, as well as central banks, that virtual currencies are not money in the legal sense of money, and do not possess a cash balance, nor the power of discharge, but rather they are – from the point of view of some – considered a «commodity», and some considered them « a means of exchange”, with some countries seeing that they perform the functions of money – to some extent – for their dealers.
The researcher combined the descriptive approach, the inductive approach, the analytical approach, and the comparative approach, using many Arabic and English references, though the Arabic references prevailed. The researcher presented the position of Arab and foreign legislation on virtual currencies and presented many Arab and foreign laws. The researcher also presented the position of the European Central Bank and the European Commission. In any case, the position of the legislation ranges between prohibiting dealing in virtual currencies and permitting them with restrictions.
The researcher presented the virtual currencies through a plan consisting of an introduction, two chapters, and a conclusion, which included findings and recommendations, and then followed it up with a list of references. In the introduction, he addressed the research problem, its importance, objectives, methodology, and divisions in the plan. In the first topic, the researcher dealt with the nature of virtual currencies, through three demands in which he presented, in order: the definition of virtual currencies, the emergence and types of virtual currencies, and the dangers of virtual currencies.
The first two requirements were divided into two parts, while the third requirement was divided into three parts. As for the second topic, the researcher dealt with the legal nature of virtual currencies, and the legal position on them, through two questions, the first of which dealt with the legal nature of virtual currencies, and in the second, the position on virtual currencies. The researcher divided the first requirement into three parts, while the second requirement was divided into three parts. In the conclusion, the researcher presented his findings and recommendations.
Keywords: digital currencies, bitcoin, blockchain, money, trading platforms.
Read Full PDF Text 323-388 Dr. Jamal A. O. Al Othman323-388 Dr. Jamal A. O. Al Othman(Arabic)