Volume 8 | Rajab – Sha’ban 1441 |
Issue 1 | March 2020 |
ISSN 24102237 |
Editorial
COVID-19 Pandemic and the Need to Improve and Modernize Legal Systems
By: Prof. Badria A. Al-Awadi
Editor-in-Chief
Suddenly, the whole world was confronted by the spread of the deadly Corona virus, of which features and ways to address it were not yet clear, except from some limited preventive measures. And in a few weeks the matter turned into a global health crisis, exacerbated by the state of ambiguity, lack of transparency and recklessness of some administrative authorities and governments of different parts of the world.
After a state of silence and confusion, the World Health Organization announced the outbreak of the coronavirus – COVID-19, at the end of January 2020, classifying it as a “public health emergency of international concern”. Then, on March 11, 2020, it declared it as a global pandemic, and urged countries to unite and cooperate in confronting and limiting the spread of the virus. As an organization funded by nations in order to preserve international public health, develop health sectors and provide health assistance to societies and countries in need, WHO failed to provide a clear scientific description of the virus nor a framework for the production of vaccines and medicines.
COVID-19 Pandemic and the Need to Improve and Modernize Legal Systems
Chief-in-Editor Prof. Badria A. Al-Awadi
Suddenly, the whole world was confronted by the spread of the deadly Corona virus, of which features and ways to address it were not yet clear, except from some limited preventive measures. And in a few weeks the matter turned into a global health crisis, exacerbated by the state of ambiguity, lack of transparency and recklessness of some administrative authorities and governments of different parts of the world.
After a state of silence and confusion, the World Health Organization announced the outbreak of the coronavirus – COVID-19, at the end of January 2020, classifying it as a “public health emergency of international concern”. Then, on March 11, 2020, it declared it as a global pandemic, and urged countries to unite and cooperate in confronting and limiting the spread of the virus. As an organization funded by nations in order to preserve international public health, develop health sectors and provide health assistance to societies and countries in need, WHO failed to provide a clear scientific description of the virus nor a framework for the production of vaccines and medicines.
Immediately after that, majority the world’s countries took the initiative to implement strict measures which ranged from closing borders, stopping flights, disrupting universities, schools, administrative and government facilities to others, in an effort to limit the spread of the virus and reduce the burden on the local health sector.
The initial weeks of this pandemic revealed great humane values in many societies, with different communities coming together in solidarity, and volunteering to aid those disadvantaged. Furthermore, it has also displayed the strength of the health, social, legal and administrative infrastructures in organizing the response to the pressing challenges of the pandemic. However, the long duration and continuity of the pandemic’s spread has left a serious impact resulting in various legal problems in need of intervention and remedy.
On the legal side, the legislations that regulate ways to confront epidemics, disasters and diseases, such as the Kuwaiti Law No. 8 of 1969 regarding health reserves for the prevention of communicable diseases, laws and administrative control procedures, have provided possibilities for a smooth and rapid transition of government and administrative agencies from normal work to exceptional emergency work in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic. The legislative intervention of the National Assembly has also contributed to filling the deficiency related to organizing and extending the deadlines for litigation in emergency situations, as well as with regards to tightening penalties for those who deliberately spread epidemics and communicable diseases, and those who violate the rules and provisions of emergency health laws and procedures.
At the same time, the events of the pandemic in a large number of countries and societies has reflected a void of legislation in governmental and private institutions and agencies during emergencies. Additionally, it has highlighted the need, once again, for an effective legislative and administrative effort to establish a general authority to deal with emergency disasters, which mission includes preparing, planning, and mobilizing resources. The effectiveness and efficiency of such a general authority has been apparent in several countries with organized frameworks put in place for responding to emergencies. Most importantly, the legal needs are not limited to the above, but they include strengthening guarantees of the right to health, by developing and increasing the human and material resources of the health sector and approving the necessary legislation for this, as well as strengthening the right to obtain information related to the epidemic, policies, plans, and governmental procedures to confront it and its spread with complete transparency.
These legal requirements also include guaranteeing freedom of opinion and expression for citizens, and strengthening the right of regulatory bodies represented in parliaments to continue their work with legislation and oversight during the pandemic period, and not to disrupt their work for any reason based on the constitutional texts that ensure their continuity even in the event of emergency. This is especially pertinent as the executive authority in its various organs continues to work. There is no doubt that these requirements also include other constitutional rights such as the right to litigation and the right to return to the country and others, whose continuity must be guaranteed under all circumstances.
Most of these constitutional and legal rights have been subjected to serious challenges during the pandemic, and the response to them has varied in different countries and societies. For instance, democratic and legal countries have always been keen to uphold the law and rights, including guaranteeing and promoting the right to health and safety, while the matter differs in relation to other countries.
The value, quality and effectiveness of constitutional, legislative and regulatory texts and regulations, as well as policies, plans and administrative procedures do not appear until they are applied and put on the ground, especially in disaster and emergency situations, as is the case with the COVID-19 pandemic, which constitutes an opportunity for review, evaluation and avoiding shortcomings and defects.
This, in turn, places a responsibility on our shoulders as workers and researchers in the legal academic field to contribute to evaluation and reform in various fields. Therefore, the Kuwait International Law School Journal welcomes research and studies dealing with the effects of this pandemic.
Content
Arabic Studies and Research
Commentary on the judgment of the Kuwaiti Court of Cassation / Second Administrative Circuit in Appeal No. 911 Administrative for the year 2019, issued in a hearing of 19/11/2019 with regard to the Nullity of Decisions Appointing 560 Experts in the Experts Department of the Ministry of Justice
Dr. Hisham Abdulsamad Al Saleh
Assistant Professor of Public Law
Kuwait International Law School
Mediation and its Impact on the Resolution of Conflicts between Muslims and the Europeans throughout the Medieval Ages From the 1st century until the end of the 9th century AH (1St Century: 9 AH/ 7th Century: 15 AD)
Dr. Attia Elwishy
Assistant Professor – History and Islamic Civilizations Department
Kuwait International Law School
Civil Liability and Artificial Intelligence … Possibility of Accountability?!: In-depth Analytical Study of the Rules of Civil Liability in French Civil Law
Prof. Mohammad E. Al Khatib
Professor of Civil Law - law Dept.
Ahmad bin Mohammad Military
College - Doha - Qatar
The Effect of Personal Consideration and the Dimensions of the Contractual Scope on the Solidarity Company: A Comparative Study between Qatari and French Legislation
Prof. Muftah Bujalal
Professor of Commercial Law
Faculty of Law and Political Science - University of Oran 2 - Algeria
Class Action for Mass Tort in Comparative Law…Towards a Special Legal Regulation in Arab Laws: Qatari and Jordanian Laws as a Model
Prof. Nisreen Salamah Mahasneh
Professor of Civil Law
College of Law - University of Qatar
Validity of the Provisions of the Constitutional Justice in Terms of Time: A Comparative Study
Dr. Esam Saeed Alubaidi
Associate Professor of Public Law
College of Law - University of Sharjah - UAE
The legitimacy of Worker Transfer Decisions within the Framework of Corporate Groups
Dr. Faraj Suleiman Hammouda
Assistant Professor of Private Law
College of Law - University of Tripoli - Libya
Commercial Act According to Legislation and «Qiyas»: Critical Study of the Second Article of the Saudi Commercial Court Law
Dr. Abdul Razzak Jajan
Associate professor of Commercial Law
Faculty of Law - University of King Abdul Aziz - Jeddah - KSA
Return to Nationality between Restitution and Recovery: A Comparative Study between the UAE and Kuwaiti Legislation
Dr. Ahmed Al Fadhli
Associate Professor of Private International Law
College of Law - University of Ajman - UAE
A New Vision of Copyright in the Information Age
Dr. Masouda Emara
Lecturer (A) - Private Law
Faculty of Law and Political Science - University of Blida 2 - Algeria
The Legal Creed (Faith) and its Contribution to Achieving the Rule of Law: Analytical study in the Philosophy of Law
Dr. Ismail Namiq Hussein
Assistant Professor of Civil Law
College of Law and Politics - University of Sulaymaniyah - Kurdistan - Iraq
The Right of Public Authority to Unilaterally Amend an Investment Contract
Dr. Saqer Al Ruwais
Assistant Professor of Public Law
College of Law - University of Bahrain
Non-profit Companies in the Kuwaiti Companies Law No. 1 of 2016
Dr. Farouk Ibrahim Jassim
Assistant Professor of Commercial Law
College of Law - University of Al-Mustansiriyah - Baghdad - Iraq
English Studies and Research
Legality of Suspension of the Intermediate – Range Nuclear Forces Treaty by the USA and Russia
Dr. Abdelnaser Aljahani
Assist. Prof. of Public International Law
College of Law - University of Sultan Qaboos - Muscat - Oman